I Challenge Non-Believers….

Yes, kind of an odd title… let’s see if I can make it flow. Yes, an anti-theist challenges all non-theists to answer a few small questions.

 

My friend PreacherOnTheWeb always puts out a sermon of sorts and I think them through, comment, and question. This latest one leads me to ask what other non-believers will or would answer:

“What do you say to yourself when you are pressed in on every side by dangerous situations? What do you do when you face troubles?”

Preacher has lots of verses and just one book that you have to keep to help you answer these questions. Since non-believers are not using that book or other holy text, how do you answer these questions?

Please let us know in the comments.

My answer is here

 

Advertisements
    • preacherontheweb
    • October 28th, 2013

    Love that challenge that you have put out there. Will watch the feedback with interest
    POTW

    • I find it interesting too… I think gnu atheists should be able to give an accounting

  1. Crom, I have never prayed to you before. I have no tongue for it. No one, not even you, will remember if we were good men or bad. Why we fought, or why we died. All that matters is that two stood against many. That’s what’s important! Valor pleases you, Crom… so grant me one request. Grant me revenge! And if you do not listen, then to HELL with you!

    • Conan, and you’ll find similar in The 13th Warrior. I liked both movies and how they treated belief. Thanks for commenting.

      • No problem. On a more serious note, when put in dire circumstances, I have no choice but to look within. Good food for thought.

      • preacherontheweb
      • October 29th, 2013

      Mmmmmm!
      “Bless me or to hell with you.”
      For a person who does not believe in the concept of Heaven or Hell, that comes as interesting.

      Fence Sitter?

      • Let me jump in. That was Conan’s prayer in ‘conan the barbarian’ and not necessarily their own viewpoint

          • preacherontheweb
          • October 29th, 2013

          Ok not their own words, but if someone goes to the trouble of quoting verbatim, one must realize that that quote will be construed as their own thoughts and feelings.

          • I work with a guy who can quote verbatim from thousands of movies… it means little on face value. The sentiment though, was further expressed as looking inside themselves and not outward for help. This is the gist of both Conan’s prayer and the dialogue in The 13th Warrior…

              • preacherontheweb
              • October 29th, 2013

              OK he said confusedly

      • No, it’s a quote from Conan The Barbarian.

  2. I say to myself, “What do I want to be able to say about myself and my conduct tomorrow?” When faced with choices about immediate decisions, I ask myself, “How will I feel about doing this choice tomorrow?” It’s surprising how often that shifting of perspective clarifies the right (or should I say ‘better’) choice of behaviour in the present.

  3. It first depends what the trouble is. In a lot of situations it is dangerous to be afraid of failing–or, more to the point, to not act because of fear of failing. So, you pick something a problem and you try to deal with it or brace yourself, let it pass and hope you learned something along the way.

    But you try and work your way out of it, normally. If the problem is a person, face that person and bargain or reason (or fight, if you have to) with them. If the problem is a situation, work on it. No matter what you do, doing something tends to get more results than clasping your hands in prayer. I don’t understand the pertinence of the question.

  4. Hey, it’s just a ride

  5. “What do you say to yourself when you are pressed in on every side by dangerous situations?”

    Try to find the safest escape from the danger like anyone else.

    “What do you do when you face troubles?”

    Try to find the best solution to the obstacle like anyone else.

    I find it most empowering to know that I’m capable of resolving my own obstacles and that I don’t have to sit around waiting for my prayers to be answered. I find my life much more manageable now that I take control of my own conflict resolution.

  6. Can I be both crass and honest? Feel free to edit if my language goes overboard.

    Oh shit! Right, what’s next? (either what is next to come at me, or what is next to solve it) is my answer to the first one.

    What do I do when I face troubles… well, hell. It would be easer to ask what I do when NOT facing troubles! Life is a never ending parade of ‘oh shit’ for me, from the washer breaking down to my dog getting bloody runs or a close friend with cancer. I was never promised a rose garden – I grew my own (and blog about it constantly, urk). It has never, ever, occurred to me that sitting on my heels and asking for help was ever going to fix any trouble I came across.

    But hey, maybe if I did sit and meditate calmly I’d have better ideas. I can see that as the only real worth of prayer.

  7. Depending on the nature of the problem, I turn to friends, my husband, or myself. There have been times I needed professional guidance, and went to a therapist.

  8. First, I curse then find out how to deal with the fucking problem and if I need help from elsewhere I would identify who among my friends I can call

    • lanceleuven
    • November 1st, 2013

    I would say the only sensible thing. “I’m going down the pub”. It always helps to put life’s woes in perspective. 🙂

    • A sensible answer indeed. Thanks for commenting

    • Matthew Chiglinsky
    • November 4th, 2013

    The word “God” is actually a very generic word that anyone can use. Some people seem to think “God” is intelligent enough to care what happens to them. (I don’t. I think God is very dumb.) Perhaps the concept of “God” is simply a way to focus one’s own willpower, and so it doesn’t really matter if you say it in an act of desperation, because it’s only an abstract concept.

    • So, you’re saying that the phrases:

      God, I love that stuff
      and
      Time is relative to the observer, I love that stuff

      may not sound sensible as each other, but they have the same philosophical and logical meaning? LOL

    • Matthew Chiglinsky
    • November 4th, 2013

    In brightest day
    In blackest night
    No evil shall escape my sight
    Let those who worship evil’s might
    Beware my power: green lantern’s light!

    LOL 🙂

    • Good one

    • Matthew Chiglinsky
    • November 4th, 2013

    • Matthew Chiglinsky
    • November 10th, 2013

    My name … is Neo!

    • that, I think, is the best of what humans can do when faced with the down and out… some of our best stories are about humans doing that exact thing

  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: